1ST Choice Energy Services®

Propane, diesel, gasoline and lubricants for farm, home and commercial needs

1st Choice Energy Propane Truck


Here Today. Here Tomorrow.

The energy division of Heritage Cooperative serves farm, residential and commercial customers in Ohio and surrounding states. Our infrastructure includes more than a dozen strategic locations and supply points, ensuring 24/7 product availability as well as a dedicated truck fleet and trained employees who are laser-focused on safety.

Our team provides a unique blend of in depth product knowledge, a keen ability to troubleshoot customer needs, flexibility in the services we provide and an ever-present focus on customer care.

Blue flame from gas heat

Contact Us

1ST Choice Energy – New Philadelphia 


1ST Choice Energy – Urbana

For the latest in energy information, find us on Facebook, join us on LinkedIn and follow us on Twitter.

1st Choice Energy propane truck at balloon festival


Competitive prices. Dependable service.

Propane is a clean burning, environmentally friendly, cost efficient and reliable source of energy. In fact, the only time most people ever think about propane is when they run out. We have 9 owned bulk storage facilities with supply purchased from multiple points across the region to ensure you have propane when you need it.

1st Choice bulk truck delivery

Heating Oil

Quality Oil at the Lowest Price

We provide high quality heating oil, at the most competitive price with local, dependable service. Our nine owned supply points ensure you can get the fuel you need when you need it.



A Full Line of Heavy-Duty Engine Oils & Lubricants

1st Choice Energy Services provides access to the highest quality lubricants, in bulk or packaged, for commercial, farm and residential uses. Our knowledgeable lubricant specialists can assist you in getting the right product at a very competitive price, delivered when you need it.

1st Choice Energy bulk delivery truck

Bulk Fuel & Equipment

Fuels For Farm, Home And Worksite

With 12 strategic locations and multiple supply points in the Midwest from Pennsylvania to Missouri, 1ST Choice Energy provides the fuels you need when you need them. We also offer an expanded product line which includes ethanol, soy biodiesel, compressed natural gas (CNG), and propane for powering trucks and school busses. 
1st Choice fuel station

Retail Fuel Stations

24/7 Public Access

We have 6 unattended fuel stations that are available to serve the customer 24/7, which is a service available to everyone, not just members.

Station Info >

Forms & Applications

Need a document or form? We've corralled all the info you need in one place.


Ask the Expert: Energy

Get your questions answered here by a member of our energy team. We’re here to help!